Can You Make Brownies In a Toaster Oven

Can You Make Brownies In a Toaster Oven? (Easiest Way Ever!!)

What is the best thing you like about brownies apart from them being the best dessert in the world? I hope you answer that it is easy to make and the recipe does not have any fancy ingredients.

It is impossible to find someone in this world who does not like biting into perfectly baked brownies as their dessert after dinner or even as an evening snack.

Another best thing about brownies?

You do not require any fancy appliances to make it. Don’t believe this? Hear this out. You can even make your brownies in a toaster oven and enjoy them hot and delicious. Unbelievable, right?

You are at the right place if you are craving some brownies and have a toaster oven in your kitchen. This article contains all the information you wish to know about making brownies in the toaster oven.

Also Read: Can You Bake Brownies In a Glass Pan? (Here’s How To Do It)

Can You Bake Brownies In A Toaster Oven?

Yes, you can absolutely bake your brownies in a toaster oven. Make sure that you don’t fail to follow the recipe from step to step. It will help you make the perfect brownies in which all the ingredients are correctly mixed and cooked nicely.

If you are somebody who belongs to a group of people who think brownies can be baked in an oven only, you need to change your ancient beliefs and thoughts regarding baking.

Brownies are versatile and can be cooked in a toaster oven without any complications. Follow the recipe for baking brownies to their core, and make sure that you do not overbake your brownies because it will make them dry and even crumbly.

There are a lot of advantages to making brownies in a toaster oven than in any other appliance. The toaster oven warms up more promptly than a conventional oven, to begin with. It does not warm up the complete kitchen, which is an additional benefit. This is why you can also make these brownies in the summer season without any problem.

Just use the appropriate smaller baking pan when baking brownies in the toaster oven. Aluminum disposable pans are pretty helpful for baking brownies in the oven.

So if you are craving some sweet dessert right now and have a toaster oven in your kitchen, bake some brownies to fulfill your cravings.

Also Read: How To Keep Brownies From Getting Hard (Four Ways) 

How To Make Brownies In A Toaster Oven?

Many people just love to bake their brownies in a toaster oven simply because they can make a small number of brownies in it. If you are also thinking of trying baking your brownies in a toaster oven and are searching for a perfect recipe, you have landed in the right place.

This recipe is very simple and short, with fifteen minutes of baking time and ten minutes of preparation time. So this means you will get your freshly home-baked brownies in just twenty-five minutes.

This recipe will yield four brownies in total, and here is a list of all the ingredients you need.

  • 1/4 cup of unsalted butter
  • Four tablespoons of all-purpose flour
  • Half a spoon of baking powder
  • Four tablespoons of brown sugar
  • One tablespoon of granulated sugar
  • One tablespoon of vanilla extract
  • Two tablespoons of cocoa powder
  • Two tablespoon coffee
  • The yolk of two eggs
  • Two large spoons of chopped chocolate

Recipe to make brownies in a toaster oven –

Step 1. Make sure that you preheat your toaster oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit. Now, take a big bowl and put all your brownie ingredients in the brownie recipe. Mix them thoroughly.

Step 2. Take another bowl and pour your butter, yolks, coffee, and vanilla into it. Stir all these ingredients until they start to come together. Now transfer this paste into the bowl containing all the dry ingredients. Thoroughly mix all the dry and wet ingredients but make sure that you do not over-mix.

Step 3. Take a small baking pan in which you plan to bake your brownies. Grease it properly with melted butter, cooking oil, or any other greasing material. Pour your prepared brownie batter into the greased baking pan.

Step 4. Now place your baking pan with the brownie batter into the preheated toaster oven. If you want the gooey center of your baked brownies, bake the brownies for fifteen minutes in the toaster oven but if you want a cakey center, bake for twenty minutes.

Do not forget to cool your brownies in the refrigerator before slicing them and serving them to yourself or your guests.

Also Read: How To Make Brownies Without Cocoa Powder (Guide!)

Tips To Make The Perfect Brownies In A Toaster Oven

If you have not tried making brownies in a toaster oven in your life and you have got your hands on the recipe mentioned above, we know It is hard to stop yourself from trying it. But before you start prepping your brownie batter, here are some tips for you that will help you make the perfect toaster oven brownies.

So get ready to make some brownies in your toaster oven, which come out as beautiful as they would have come out from a regular oven.

Choose the right size of baking pan in accordance with your toaster oven

If you have a toaster oven in your kitchen, you may be acquainted with the fact that it does not come with a baking pan but only with a tray. This is the reason why you have to buy one baking pan according to the size of your toaster. To find the right size pan, measure your oven from the inside.

Grease your baking pan and line it with parchment paper

It is not one of the tips but more of a general reminder to grease your baking pan with oil, ghee, or melted butter and then line it with parchment paper. It will really help you and save you time scratching the base of your baking pan when you take out your baked brownies. It is not essential whether you are making a cakey brownie or a fudgy one. Every type sticks to the bottom of the baking pan.

Adjust your baking time according to the heat level of your toaster oven

The problem with the oven toaster is that it does not have settings to change the heat. It only comes with the timer dial, and this is the reason why you have to pay extra attention to the heat and temperature of the oven’s inside.

Because of this, baking time can differ from one toaster oven to another. Though, on average, baking time is fifteen minutes, you should check your brownies every five minutes.

Also Read: Can Brownies Be Left Out Overnight (Tips To Keep Them Fresh)


How long should I bake my brownies in a toaster oven?

What could be more magical than baking your favorite dessert recipe in the handiest appliance in your kitchen – a toaster oven? Nothing.

If you are not already using your toaster oven for baking brownies, then you have to because it is a really easy way and brownies come out way too incredible. Just set your toaster oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit and bake your brownies for around fifteen to twenty minutes.

Just bake your brownies for about 15 minutes if you want your brownies gooey and chewy. But if you want your brownies to have more of a cakey texture, bake them for around 20 minutes.

Can you make boxed brownies in a toaster oven?

Yes, you can absolutely bake your box of brownies in a toaster oven. You might be aware of how delicious and beautiful brownies are made in the toaster oven, and with no exception, box brownies are also the best thing that can come out of the oven.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, making brownies in the toaster oven is the best solution if you are just planning to make a small batch. In comparison to baking brownies in a standard household oven, baking in a toaster oven uses much less energy.

It is pretty normal for anyone to feel uneasy while baking brownies in an oven toaster for the first time. But by taking this baby step, you will get used to your kitchen equipment, and who knows, you may attempt to bake a different recipe in your toaster oven the next time.

While baking brownies in the toaster oven, you must keep an eye on your brownies since a toaster oven’s temperature might be challenging to regulate. But if you follow these steps, baking brownies in a toaster oven is probably the best idea.

Leave a Reply